On this page:

We trust the people of Scotland to make the right decisions and ask other parties to do the same.

Bruce Crawford, Minister for Parliamentary Business

Friday, November 30, 2007

The online conversation is undoubtedly off to a flying start.

Bruce Crawford Minister for Parliamentary BusinessThe 1,000th comment in the National Conversation Blog was posted at 7.26am on Saturday morning. And the conversation continues to grow and expand in new places with the First Minister speaking to a packed out audience at Edinburgh's International Book Festival, radio phone ins and newspaper letters pages fill up with the views of the nation.

It seems that articulating debate on our constitutional future is hugely popular with a poll in a Sunday newspaper this weekend showing that 74 per cent of Scots are in favour of a referendum with the majority believing that Scotland becoming Independent in inevitable.

The Scottish Government envisages a national conversation which will consider the entire range of possible improvements to the current constitutional settlement for Scotland. What is clear is that the status quo is no longer an option and the question now is how much more Independence and responsibility the people of Scotland want to help improve and progress our country? For instance, I want Scotland to have the Independence to decide whether the Trident Nuclear Weapons System should continue to be based on the Clyde.

At the election a few months back all the main political parties made proposals concerning the devolution settlement.

In addition to proposing a white paper on independence which we have now published, the Scottish National Party made specific proposals to extend the devolution settlement in areas such as the civil service, broadcasting and for firearms.

The Scottish Liberal Democrats proposed a new constitutional convention to examine the best way to devolve new responsibilities, including taxation, to Holyrood. They also proposed that competence over the electoral system, energy, transport and marine policy should be devolved.

The Scottish Labour party emphasised the continued use of the mechanisms in the Scotland Act to make any necessary changes. The Scottish Conservatives declared themselves open to a debate about the powers of the Scottish Parliament to secure accountability for raising revenues, as well as for spending.

Since we launched the national conversation many politicians have joined the debate, with some rethinking their position and saying they welcome a fresh look at Scotland's partnership with other parts of the UK. Certainly times change and minds change, and what is important is that Scotland's government encourages the debate and enables political parties, groups and individuals who have a view of the future direction our nation to play a full part in the conversation.

At the end of the day whether the people of Scotland choose full self government as the way forward or seek to obtain new devolved powers for the Scottish Parliament no significant change should be allowed to happen without the consent of the people, that is why we so strongly back the idea of a referendum. We trust the people of Scotland to make the right decisions and ask other parties to do the same.

Before the election we said to Scotland that it was now time to move forward. As we approach our first 100 days of an SNP Government we have done just that by getting on with the job of delivering the SNP programme and fulfilling our commitment to ensure that a full and proper debate setting out how we can choose a new and better relationship with the other nations of these islands takes place. I look forward to the conversation flowing!

This blog is now closed to further comments.

Comments

[Latest First] | [Earliest First] Page: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15]

  • 71. Alex Moffat - Livingston

    Monday, August 27, 2007 17:12

    I have been a "socialist" all my adult life and a Labour voter. I may continue to support Labour once Scotland is independent - who knows. I voted the SNP in the last election because I believed with so many that "the time is right". I support the "conversation" and will vote in favour of independence for Scotland when (not if) we have a referendum,

  • 72. John Purves - Upper Largo

    Monday, August 27, 2007 19:41

    For too long we have been told by the unionist parties that we are
    incapabable of running our own affairs.
    A referendum is the right way to allow Scotland to choose its own destiny. Independance is the way forward for Scotland and it is our opportunity to join the international community of nations in peaceful cooperation and trade as our nordic neighbours do.

  • 73. Ian Innes - Elgin

    Monday, August 27, 2007 20:34

    re my blog no 64 of the 26th instant.

    To correct my final comment 'When we do I will again vote conservative' .I meant ,of course, 'for an Independent Scottish Conservative Party'.

    Ian Innes

  • 74. John Patton - Valencia Spain.

    Monday, August 27, 2007 22:24

    For once Scotland has the chance to vote for change. We have the chance to stand up, be counted and once more have what is ours, Alba and freedom. Scotland must be controlled by the people of Scotland. We sat back and watched India, Hong Kong and other areas free themselves from the "Empire" yet we never looked at ourselves. As the sun finally sets on the British Empire we find ourselves as one of the last occupied lands. We are able to control our nation, stand up for ourselves and bring back our Scottish troops. Is it right that a leader of a foreign land sends our young men to fight their war and die?

  • 75. Disgusted Dorothy - Glasgow

    Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:45

    I fail to understand why the labour,liberals and sundries are so against asking the Scottish people a question.
    The attitude of the liberal party has perplexed me.Willing to join forces with war mongerers but unwilling to join with a party who only want to ask THE QUESTION.
    Could some little liberal explain that to me??
    I did try to get an answer from a BIG liberal in May but they rubber eared me!

  • 76. Frank Orr - Glasgow

    Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:35

    Nobody is answering the question why we can`t govern ourselves as the main opposition parties are concerned about breaking away from the union,well we don`t need to look far as countries neighbouring our own have successfully governed themselves for centuries and have pretty well stable and thriving economies

  • 77. George Steel - Glenrothes

    Tuesday, August 28, 2007 13:20

    Perhaps it has escaped the attention of those ex-pats who have travelled the world and seen how 'wonderful' it is to live in a free independent state that Scotland has achieved remarkable developments and improvements through membership of the UK. I have lived here for all of my 65+ years and raised a family with my wife of over 40 years. We both vote for unionist parties, and have never had any difficulty promoting our pride in being Scottish while maintaining our British nationality. Would a Texan be any less American, if Texas became an independent state?

    If we do become independent does that mean sit out of Europe or do we become affiliated with that group?

    Do we have to join NATO? whatwould be the cost of an army, navy and aor force? Too many unanswered questions for me.

  • 78. Martin Green - Kirkcaldy

    Tuesday, August 28, 2007 13:21

    Of course we are capable of governing ourselves. The question there is what would such a Scotland be like? Just reading the paper today that 35% of older Glaswegians are work-shy makes me wonder.
    However, all this is just conjecture and we are all being sucked into Alex' game; he is just another politician and what do politicians want? - more power. All Alex wants is to strut his stuff on a bigger stage! Wake up Scots - a bird in the hand and all that!

  • 79. CASEY PURVIS - WEST HILLS, CALIF

    Tuesday, August 28, 2007 21:11

    I, FOR THE LIFE OF ME, CANNOT EVEN IMAGINE
    SOMEONE TELLING ME WHAT TO DO. ASKING PERMISSION?? ANOTHER COUNTRY DECIDING WHAT I WILL DO?
    MY GOD, LET SCOTSMEN BE SCOTSMEN. FIGHT FOR YOURSELVES, YOUR OWN HONOR.
    LONG LIVE SCOTLAND.
    INDEPENDENCE
    CASEY PURVIS
    HELL I'LL COME OVER AND FIGHT

  • 80. John McGroarty - Antwerpen, België

    Wednesday, August 29, 2007 11:40

    At present I live in the Flemish region of Belgium as I did have to "get on my bike" many years ago due to the decimation of Scottish industry. I have worked in similar small nations around the EU and have noticed how well looked after the people are. Belgium has one of the best infra-structure on the planet and a fantastic healthcare system although a bit of a political shambles. Like Scotland, Flanders would be much better on its own. The future is for local government looking after the interests of its peoples via EU. If there is enough resources and exports then even the EU could be an opt out (for example Norway).

[Latest First] | [Earliest First] Page: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15]

Page updated: Tuesday, May 13, 2008