On this page:

We trust the people of Scotland to make the right decisions and ask other parties to do the same.

Bruce Crawford, Minister for Parliamentary Business

Friday, November 30, 2007

The online conversation is undoubtedly off to a flying start.

Bruce Crawford Minister for Parliamentary BusinessThe 1,000th comment in the National Conversation Blog was posted at 7.26am on Saturday morning. And the conversation continues to grow and expand in new places with the First Minister speaking to a packed out audience at Edinburgh's International Book Festival, radio phone ins and newspaper letters pages fill up with the views of the nation.

It seems that articulating debate on our constitutional future is hugely popular with a poll in a Sunday newspaper this weekend showing that 74 per cent of Scots are in favour of a referendum with the majority believing that Scotland becoming Independent in inevitable.

The Scottish Government envisages a national conversation which will consider the entire range of possible improvements to the current constitutional settlement for Scotland. What is clear is that the status quo is no longer an option and the question now is how much more Independence and responsibility the people of Scotland want to help improve and progress our country? For instance, I want Scotland to have the Independence to decide whether the Trident Nuclear Weapons System should continue to be based on the Clyde.

At the election a few months back all the main political parties made proposals concerning the devolution settlement.

In addition to proposing a white paper on independence which we have now published, the Scottish National Party made specific proposals to extend the devolution settlement in areas such as the civil service, broadcasting and for firearms.

The Scottish Liberal Democrats proposed a new constitutional convention to examine the best way to devolve new responsibilities, including taxation, to Holyrood. They also proposed that competence over the electoral system, energy, transport and marine policy should be devolved.

The Scottish Labour party emphasised the continued use of the mechanisms in the Scotland Act to make any necessary changes. The Scottish Conservatives declared themselves open to a debate about the powers of the Scottish Parliament to secure accountability for raising revenues, as well as for spending.

Since we launched the national conversation many politicians have joined the debate, with some rethinking their position and saying they welcome a fresh look at Scotland's partnership with other parts of the UK. Certainly times change and minds change, and what is important is that Scotland's government encourages the debate and enables political parties, groups and individuals who have a view of the future direction our nation to play a full part in the conversation.

At the end of the day whether the people of Scotland choose full self government as the way forward or seek to obtain new devolved powers for the Scottish Parliament no significant change should be allowed to happen without the consent of the people, that is why we so strongly back the idea of a referendum. We trust the people of Scotland to make the right decisions and ask other parties to do the same.

Before the election we said to Scotland that it was now time to move forward. As we approach our first 100 days of an SNP Government we have done just that by getting on with the job of delivering the SNP programme and fulfilling our commitment to ensure that a full and proper debate setting out how we can choose a new and better relationship with the other nations of these islands takes place. I look forward to the conversation flowing!

This blog is now closed to further comments.

Comments

[Latest First] | [Earliest First] Page: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15]

  • 31. Tam McMurray - Edinburgh

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 08:54

    I think it is about time we took our destiny in our own hands. We are a proud and diverse nation and i think it is time we had our independance.

    Lets change history and enjoy all of the benifits of indepedance.

  • 32. jack colquhoun - Cowdenbeath

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 10:03

    It's Time to wake up and smell the heather lads and lasses.Time for Independant Democracy ne'er Dictatorship from those elected by us their ultimate employers!!!
    More devolved powers to a only halfcocked parliament,gladly now with MSP's in minority willing to stand up to those with only keeping their jobs a concern pressured enough to conform to the obvious change in the political arena.To all the doubting Thomas' aye ask pro-act and engage in the debate,question those who represent you,re-action is ill informed,speculative and non productive.Actions speak louder than words,Labour said they were
    listening????
    Now their listening to what The SNP have engaged the voter with Politics for Scotland's sake.We need to face the facts The SNP cannot acheive our wishes alone,our monies are used to impliment these changes,the result justifies the accountability of a party prepared to ACT ne'er REACT as we see from previous administrations.
    We need now to speculate to accumulate before it becomes too late in the day and we allow Political Tyrany to overshadow Today's Democracy.
    Let's move forward with the political winds of change and amass a Tornado of pro-active policies bringing Scotland into The 21st Century.One never knows perhaps Alex's William Wallace style will be matched by Gordy becoming a 21st Century Robert The Bruce????
    If not so what let's just get on wi' the job in hand PROGRESS!!!!

  • 33. Steve - Annan

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 11:16

    I have lived in Scotland for the past 20 years and my children were born here. I have always been a tory but after living here for so long I can see now that the SNP are the answer and the way forward, and I fully support the chance for independence. I have now just joined the SNP as my way of supporting them. I look forward to a new, bright future for Scotland and feel pround that I live here. Hope a new Scotland will however rid us of the youth violence the UK has been blighted with.

  • 34. louise - inverclyde

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 11:38

    I am really annoyed at the media at the moment the standard of political reporting in scotland at the moment is frankly appalling they should hang their heads in shame. Same goes for the bbc. The only paper that seems to be going some way to reporting political issues is the herald. I want to see reports of this coversation as well as other political issues. Its a sad day when you have to look outside our country for information relating to it. I want to know where and when the public meetings are going to be. I want to see the papers reporting the facts and adding to the debate not stifling it.

  • 35. Chris Morris - Dundee

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 11:56

    For my whole life I have always wanted independence for my country. Now that it seems that it may happen in the near future, it really excites me, but I'm afraid I will be very much saddened if we don't get it.

    I think it is only right that we should become an independent nation. I don't agree with people in England having the biggest say in how we live our lives. We are more than ready to become a free country, and I strongly agree that our country shouldn't be lead into illigal wars, and I don't want any nucular weapons dumped in our country. We should be a peaceful nation, and if we get independence, we will be.

  • 36. Derek Wilson - Shawlands

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 13:13

    Conversation with Andrew Brown (28). The status quo is no longer an option since every major political Party in Scotland has to varying extents publicly agreed on this. And since these parties carried 97%+ of the electoral vote, it appears the electors of Scotland concur. If we secede from Westminster we will be "governed" from Brussels in exactly the same way as Westminster is currently "governed" from Brussels; except we will have seats at the discussions which fundamentally affect Scotland, and importantly we'll have nearly 3 times as many of those seats. There is plenty of published legal opinion that a cedeing state of a current member would not be forced to reapply but would be assimilated, and bearing in mind the high regard in which Scotland is held throughout Europe, who would object?

  • 37. Colin - Walton

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 13:45

    34. louise - inverclyde
    Thursday, August 23, 2007 11:38

    "I am really annoyed at the media at the moment the standard of political reporting in scotland at the moment is frankly appalling they should hang their heads in shame. Same goes for the bbc. The only paper that seems to be going some way to reporting political issues is the herald. I want to see reports of this coversation as well as other political issues. Its a sad day when you have to look outside our country for information relating to it. I want to know where and when the public meetings are going to be. I want to see the papers reporting the facts and adding to the debate not stifling it. "

    I am completely with you on this one louise, the Herald has gone some way to giving a non-partisan coverage, but we need more of it. This is our opportunity as a nation to debate what is surely the most important decision that our country has faced in living memory. All of the Scottish media should be engaging in this, regardless of their political leanings, and allowing the people access to the facts so that we might excercise our right to decide for ourselves.

  • 38. David Robertson - Inverness

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 13:54

    I am disappointed that nothing has been done to improve the "conversation" aspect of this website. I personally made several suggestions and others have done likewise. There have been many intelligent contributions and I have read them all. However, it is impossible to engage with any of the writers since we have to plough through every post to find out if there has been a response.

    I would dearly love to pursue a discussion of the pros and cons of being in or out of the EU. This will have a significant bearing on whether I personally support independence.

    As presently advertised, the SNP position seems to favour EU membership which they appear to regard as assisting their case for "independence". If this is true then the aims of the SNP and those of the faceless bureaucrats in Brussels are identical. The EU is presently set on a course to regionalise "Europa" entirely and governed, top-down, from the centre. It will make the old arrangement of being run from Westminster look like freedom. Nation states will be a thing of the past, Scotland will be merely a small region of Europa, and we shall be indoctrinated to see ourselves as Europeans. If this is the object of this exercise, and I am convinced it is, then let us look at that and decide if we want it.

    The other political parties must be aware that this is the end game and their present posturing is all for our benefit to give us a bit of dramatic conflict.

    Until these facts are made clear by the SNP and a definite option of independence outside the EU placed on the table I shall remain sceptical that true independence is the goal of any of our dear leaders.

  • 39. jack reid - glasgow

    Thursday, August 23, 2007 20:03

    In time there will be another Tory government in Britain.Maybe not in five years or ten years ,but it will happen.Does Scotland really want to be run by them again? The only way to stop this happening is to vote for an independant Scotland in a referendum. Let's have one.

  • 40. Rom - Falkirk

    Friday, August 24, 2007 11:15

    I think that the Scottish Parliment's willingness to allow this nonsense to occur when the SNP have a majority of one MSP is disgraceful, the people voted in May and the result of no clear majority is clear to see that the country is not willing to accept the idea of independence from a bunch of saber rattling fools who think it is the solution to all our ails. Do they honestly believe Westminster would just pack up their military bases and investments up here, give a cheery smile and leave? no, a vote of no-confidence is needed immediately to destroy this SNP charade Government and let them realise what reality is.

[Latest First] | [Earliest First] Page: [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15]

Page updated: Tuesday, May 13, 2008